In a significant ruling on November 5, 2023, the Delhi High Court affirmed that foreign nationals cannot claim an enforceable right to enter India based on the possession of a multiple-entry tourist visa or its validity. The court's decision, released on Tuesday, emphasizes that the issuance, refusal, or clearance at immigration is a sovereign function of the Indian government, influenced by factors such as national security, foreign policy, and administrative discretion.

A US citizen filed a petition with the court, seeking directions for the Indian government to allow her entry into India. She had been issued a multiple-entry tourist visa on November 28, 2022, valid until November 27, 2032. However, during her visit in January 2024, immigration authorities informed her that her cumulative stay in the country had exceeded the permissible limit of 180 days. Despite paying the prescribed penalty, no order or exit permit was issued to her. Upon her arrival at Bengaluru airport on November 4, 2024, she was denied entry and told she could return only after April 9, 2026.

The US national also claimed that her application for a Medical/AYUSH Visa to receive treatment in India was rejected without any reasons assigned. The court, however, dismissed the plea, stating it is not its role to substitute its assessment for that of the competent authority in matters concerning foreign national admissions. It also emphasized that the visa possession does not confer an absolute or unconditional right of admission into India.