In a contentious development, an analysis by the Civic Research Group (CRG) has revealed that over 27,000 voters cleared by judicial officers in West Bengal's special intensive revision (SIR) process are facing appeals against their inclusion in the electoral roll. This appeal, filed by the West Bengal Chief Electoral Officer’s (CEO) office, is part of a larger pool of 1.6 million appeals filed against inclusion before judicial tribunals in the state. The Election Commission of India (ECI) has stated that these appeals are technical in nature and do not imply ineligibility to vote for the cleared voters.
The disputed votes come from 7,335 polling booths across 23 districts in West Bengal. These booths held voters whose names appeared in the supplementary lists, indicating their eligibility to vote in the assembly elections. The analysis found that of these voters, approximately 79% were pending appeals and 21% had been disposed of, with the status of successful disposals remaining unclear. Notably, all 294 assembly constituencies in the state had at least one such disputed booth.
Among districts, Kalimpong, Purba Bardhaman, and Darjeeling saw the largest proportion of appeals against inclusion. On the other hand, Dakshin Dinajpur, Cooch Behar, and Nadia reported the lowest proportion of appeals. The developments bring renewed focus to the controversial logical discrepancy process implemented in West Bengal for the first time, which resulted in the exclusion of 5.8 million voters and the prospect of further exclusions due to name mismatches, typos, age gaps, and number of children.
The current situation involves 19 appellate tribunals hearing both deleted voters appealing against their exclusion and CEO officials appealing against the inclusion of certain voters. The 1.6 million appeals filed by election officials represent roughly half of the 3.28 million people cleared by judicial officers, with approximately 1.5 million appeals still pending and 81,242 disposed of as per CRG's data from the tribunal’s appeal portal. The ECI has declined to comment on the matter.
