The Supreme Court of India has ruled that a grandson cannot claim coparcenary rights in his grandfather's ancestral property after it has been partitioned among the grandfather's legal heirs. The ruling, delivered on November 6 by Justices Augustine George Masih and Sunita Agarwal, stated that once the property devolved upon the grandfather's Class I legal heirs and was divided among them, the joint coparcenary ceased to exist. The grandson could not subsequently claim a share in the property allotted to his father merely on the basis of his birth.
The case originated in 1997 when the appellant, then a minor, and his mother filed a suit seeking partition and possession of half of a 1,811-square-foot property in Chennai. The appellant claimed that he had acquired a coparcenary interest in the property by birth. However, the property had already been divided among his grandfather's legal heirs following a partition suit instituted in 1993 by the appellant's paternal aunt. A compromise decree was passed on February 3, 1994, under which the appellant's father, who was one of the legal heirs, received a share measuring 1,811 square feet.
Rejecting the grandson's claim, the Supreme Court explained that when a Hindu male dies intestate, his property devolves upon the Class I heirs under the 1956 Act. A grandson whose father is alive is not included in the list of Class I heirs and cannot claim a direct share in his grandfather's property through succession. The court relied on its earlier ruling in Commissioner of Wealth Tax Vs Chander Sen (1986), which held that property inherited by a son under the 1956 Act devolves upon him in his individual capacity and does not automatically become Hindu undivided family property as regards to his own son.
The bench also rejected the reliance on Section 29-A of the Hindu Succession (Tamil Nadu Amendment) Act, 1989, and the unamended Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, holding that neither provision could confer coparcenary rights on the appellant in the facts of the case. The summary does not include names, numbers or claims that are not in the original text.
