The Supreme Court has requested a response from the Central government and its Secretary General regarding a petition that calls for the finalization of an amended Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) for appointing judges to constitutional courts. The MoP serves as a guideline for the appointment, elevation, and transfer of high court and Supreme Court judges. The petition was filed by Lok Prahari, an NGO, who expressed concern over the delay in finalizing the MoP, despite a 2015 directive from a Constitution Bench that aimed to improve the Collegium system for appointing judges.
Following a Supreme Court judgment that sought improved functioning of the Collegium system, an order was passed on December 16, 2025, instructing the Central government to finalize the existing MoP by incorporating decisions made by the Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant based on the unanimous view of the top court's four senior-most judges. The petition also advocated for bringing the minutes of the selection process conducted by the Supreme Court and High Courts Collegiums under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.
The petition asserts that the existing MoP lacks transparency and objectivity, which can affect the quality and performance of judges in constitutional courts, thereby impacting the litigants' right to justice. The Union of India and the CJI through the Secretary General were named as respondents in the petition due to the 2015 order requiring the CJI to decide on the MoP based on the unanimous view of the Collegium.
The petition argues that a decade is more than sufficient to comply with the Constitution Bench's decision, and the delay in implementation constitutes a persistent breach of duty on the part of the Central government. The petition urges the court to direct the finalization of the MoP within a month, ensuring transparency and objectivity in the selection process by making the minutes of High Court and Supreme Court Collegium meetings accessible to the public under the RTI Act.
