In a landmark decision, the Delhi High Court has criticized the Staff Selection Commission (SSC) for adopting a restrictive interpretation of eligibility criteria and rejecting the application of a qualified nurse. The court's remarks came during a hearing against a Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) order from January 29, 2023, which favored a woman whose nursing officer (allopathic) post application was initially denied.

The candidate, who held a post-basic BSc nursing qualification, was rejected because she registered after the prescribed cut-off date. The woman appealed to the CAT, and her application was accepted due to the fact that she received a certificate from the Delhi Nursing Council in 2018, prior to the cut-off date. The SSC then challenged this order in the high court, arguing that the 2018 certificate should not have been considered because it was issued before the candidate obtained the necessary BSc qualification as specified in the advertisement.

The Delhi High Court dismissed the SSC's petition and reprimanded them for their narrow interpretation of eligibility criteria. The court also emphasized that professional doctors and nurses are vital assets to society, and those who meet the prescribed qualifications should not be excluded unjustifiably. The SSC has been given four weeks to comply with the CAT's ruling.

Furthermore, the court expressed disappointment over the SSC's decision to challenge the CAT order instead of accepting it. In its November 2 verdict, released on November 6, the court stated, "We feel that the SSC ought to have graciously accepted the order of the Tribunal instead of challenging it..." The court's ruling underscores the importance of considering qualified candidates for positions and avoiding unnecessary restrictions in the interpretation of eligibility criteria.