CPI(M) Member of Parliament (MP) Su Venkatesan has strongly refuted Madras High Court judge Justice GR Swaminathan's criticism regarding his lifestyle, asserting that he has never owned a car and describing the judge's comments as a "cheap personal attack." The controversy arose after Justice Swaminathan criticized Venkatesan for questioning his judicial responsibilities while referring to his alleged luxury vehicle and branded clothing. In response, Venkatesan issued a statement on Tuesday clarifying that he has never owned a car and defended his travel choices, maintaining they were in accordance with official travel entitlements for MPs. He also dismissed the judge's comparison between their respective travel arrangements, arguing that one's ideological position cannot be determined by the class of travel. Venkatesan reiterated his commitment to communist ideology and took pride in being part of the Left movement. The CPI(M) Tamil Nadu secretary also condemned Justice Swaminathan's remarks and urged appropriate action from the Chief Justice, accusing the judge of departing from judicial norms and displaying personal and ideological biases.

On Monday, during an open-court hearing, Justice Swaminathan took exception to Venkatesan's criticism of his judicial responsibilities. The disagreement originated after the judge suggested that spiritual books on the late Kanchi Shankaracharya be placed in the vacant shelves of the Periyar Arivulagam Library in Coimbatore as an "atonement" for the alleged irregularities in book procurement. Venkatesan criticized this suggestion, arguing that corruption in library procurement is a criminal matter requiring legal action rather than atonement.

The controversy has now widened into a debate over judicial conduct, ideological differences, and the propriety of personal remarks from the bench.